8. Islamic crimes on Brahmins’ account - In white washing various
deeds of the medieval Islamic rulers the Marxist historians have tried so
many techniques. One of them is to blame Hindu society, especially the
Brahmins, for some infamous acts of the past. For instance, the
destructions of Buddhist and Jain temples are frequently put on the
account of Hindus, without, of course, a shred of evidence. Killing
several birds by one: concealing Islamic record of brutal iconoclasm;
demonstrating the Hindu ‘intolerance’ instead; creating rift between
Hindus and Buddhists, Jains on the one hand; and within Hindus on the
bases of caste differences, etc on the other. It is all very helpful to
left-wing politicking at present.
9. Marxist intervention on Ayodhya - The Marxist historians
intervention in the Ayodhya dispute in 1989 was an act of pure political
activism. The entire episode, still continuing, demonstrated that the
eminent historians are political activists first, then anything else.
Their intervention began in the ruse of presenting ‘the historical
evidence’ regarding the dispute. It soon became clear that they were
astonishingly poor on the very historical evidence. They wrote a
highfalutin pamphlet with the signature of 25 historians, and the official
publisher being the Centre for Historical Studies, JNU. But as soon as the
pamphlet was examined by knowledgeable individuals the very historians
became champions of secularist politics saying ‘evidence or no evidence’.
That their home work was so poor speaks volumes of the quality of their
scholarship. Besides, they botched up the entire issue, encouraged the
Muslim side to become uncompromising and vitiated the socio-political
atmosphere by their childish political adventurism, and later, escapism. A
good specimen of the worth of their eminences.
10. Enmity with Hinduism – In their writings, speeches and activism
a distinct streak of anti-Hindu attitude is always discernible. Whence it
comes from may be varied, but the fact remains that most of the Marxist
historians do not even conceal their hatred for Hindu tradition, deities,
ethos, etc. Their contempt of everything Hindu is apparent in their work.
In some cases it